.webp)
One Missed Photo Could Cost You the Entire Deposit
A tenant moves out. You walk the unit, find a stained carpet and a chipped countertop, and deduct $600 from the deposit without a second thought. Six months ago, that would have been the end of it. Starting January 1, 2026, that same deduction could cost you the entire deposit, plus penalties, if you can't prove the damage with dated photos and a signed move-in checklist.
Colorado's new HB25-1249 rewrites the rules around security deposits, and the changes are significant enough that Denver landlords need to understand them before their next move-out. My Haven has spent over 30 years managing rental properties across the Denver metro, and we've built our maintenance and turnover process around exactly this kind of documentation. Here's what the law actually requires, and why photo evidence is no longer optional.
Key Takeaways
A 125% threshold now defines wrongful withholding. Deduct more than 125% of your actual, documented repair costs, and the law presumes you acted in bad faith.
Losing a dispute means losing everything. Wrongful withholding forfeits the landlord's right to any portion of the deposit and can trigger additional statutory penalties.
Deposits are capped at one month's rent, tightening the cushion landlords have historically relied on.
The burden of proof has shifted to landlords. You must now prove damage occurred during the tenancy, not the resident disprove it.
Photo documentation and move-in/move-out checklists are essential, since vague notes, memory, or general descriptions no longer hold up in a dispute.
What HB25-1249 Actually Changes
The 125% Penalty Threshold
Under the new law, if you withhold an amount that exceeds 125% of your actual, verifiable repair costs, that retention is legally presumed wrongful. There's no gray area for rounding up or padding an estimate.
What it means: If a repair genuinely costs $400, you cannot withhold more than $500 and expect that decision to survive a challenge. Anything above that threshold shifts the legal presumption against you, even if you believe the higher number was justified.
Real-world example: A resident's dog damages a bedroom door, and repair quotes come in at $350. If you withhold $600 to cover "general wear and tear" you noticed elsewhere without documentation, you've likely crossed the 125% line, putting the entire deposit at risk.
Severe Penalties for Wrongful Withholding
This is the part that should get every landlord's attention. Wrongful withholding doesn't just mean returning the disputed amount. It means forfeiting the right to keep any portion of the deposit, plus potential statutory penalties on top of that.
What it means: A single miscalculated or undocumented deduction can wipe out legitimate damages you absolutely could have collected, simply because the process wasn't followed correctly.
Strict Caps on Deposit Amounts
Security deposits are now capped at a maximum of one month's rent. Landlords who have historically collected 1.5x or 2x rent as a deposit, particularly for pet owners or higher-risk applicants, will need to adjust their resident screening and risk mitigation strategy accordingly.
What it means: With less deposit to work with and a lower margin for error, every dollar withheld needs to be defensible.
No Charging for Pre-Existing Conditions
Landlords cannot deduct money for any defect or damage that existed before the tenancy began. This makes a documented move-in condition report just as important as a move-out one.
What it means: Without a baseline record from day one, you have no way to prove a scuff, stain, or crack wasn't already there when the resident moved in.
Why Photo Documentation Is Now Non-Negotiable
The Burden of Proof Has Flipped
Historically, disputes often came down to a landlord's word against a resident's. Under the new framework, the burden falls on the landlord to prove that damage occurred during the tenancy and wasn't pre-existing or normal wear and tear.
What it means: "I remember it being fine when they moved in" is not evidence. Time-stamped photos, video walkthroughs, and signed checklists are the only documentation that reliably holds up.
Vague Notes and Memory No Longer Hold Up
General descriptions like "kitchen needed cleaning" or "some wall damage" won't survive a challenge. Courts and arbitrators are looking for specific, dated, photographic evidence tied directly to a documented condition report.
Real-world example: Two landlords each deduct $300 for a damaged wall. One has a clear, dated photo from move-in showing an undamaged wall and a matching move-out photo showing the hole. The other has a handwritten note that simply says "wall damage." Under the new burden of proof, only one of those deductions is likely to survive a dispute.
Normal Wear and Tear Is Now Strictly Defined
The law draws a much firmer line around what counts as normal wear and tear. Carpet buckling, fading paint, and minor wall scuffs are explicitly defined as normal wear and cannot be charged to the resident, regardless of how they look at move-out.
The Carpet Rule Landlords Need to Know
One of the more specific provisions in the law addresses flooring directly: carpet cannot be deemed ruined unless it is less than 10 years old and shows substantial, irreparable damage. A worn-out 12-year-old carpet, no matter how bad it looks, generally cannot be charged back to a departing resident.
What it means: Age and condition records for major components like flooring now matter for deposit disputes, not just for your own capital planning.
Building a Documentation System That Protects You
The practical takeaway from HB25-1249 is simple: your paper trail is now your primary defense. That means:
A detailed, photo-backed move-in checklist signed by the resident
Time-stamped photos at both move-in and move-out, covering every room
Repair invoices and quotes that match the actual amount withheld
A clear separation between damage and normal wear and tear before any deduction is made
This is exactly the kind of process-driven work we handle for owners through our full-service property management in Denver, backed by our guarantees that protect your investment at every stage of the resident lifecycle.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does HB25-1249 apply to leases signed before January 1, 2026?
The law governs how deposits are handled and returned starting on its effective date, so move-outs and deposit determinations occurring after January 1, 2026 fall under the new rules, even if the original lease was signed earlier.
What happens if I withhold a fair amount but don't have photos?
Without documentation, you may struggle to prove the deduction was justified if the resident disputes it. Given the shifted burden of proof, a lack of evidence puts even legitimate deductions at risk of being classified as wrongful withholding.
Can I still charge for damage caused by pets?
Yes, genuine pet damage beyond normal wear and tear can still be deducted, provided it's documented with photos and doesn't exceed 125% of the actual, verifiable repair cost.
Protect Every Deposit Decision You Make
HB25-1249 doesn't ban security deposit deductions. It demands proof. Denver landlords who build a consistent documentation habit, dated photos, signed checklists, and matched invoices, will navigate this law without issue. Those who rely on memory or vague notes are taking on real financial risk with every move-out.
My Haven Group has built move-in and move-out documentation into our standard process for every property we manage across Denver and the surrounding metro. If you want a system that keeps you compliant and protected, contact us to schedule a consultation.
